Shellfish deaths: MPs call for review of dredging in River Tees
Joe RedfernAn urgent review of dredging in the River Tees is needed following the mass deaths of shellfish, a cross-party parliamentary committee has said.
The Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee also called for more research into the die-offs in 2021.
The MPs want an expert panel to examine conflicting theories about the cause of the deaths and a fund set up to help fishers whose catches have reduced.
Government scientists say algae was to blame but fishers reject their claims.
Last week, the committee heard evidence of two theories for the cause of huge numbers of crustacean deaths in October 2021.
Defra has ruled the consequences of the breakdown of algal bloom is the most likely cause but some academics, commissioned by the North East Fishing Collective, believe a chemical called pyridine is responsible.
They argue pyridine could have been released by maintenance dredging of the Tees.
Sir Robert Goodwill, chair of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee, has now written to the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Thérèse Coffey with the committee's interim findings.
Joe RedfernIn the letter, he called for:
- More research into the causes of the die-offs - including an investigation into where pyridine may have come from and sampling of the Tees Estuary to create a map of potential pyridine sources
- Collaboration in testing between government agencies and the wider scientific community
- The appointment of an expert independent panel to review all the evidence
- An urgent review of dredging in the Tees - to be carried out by the Marine Management Organisation (MMO)
- The MMO should explore what steps could be taken to improve dredging, including: preventing sediment escaping, considering changes to the depth and intensity of dredging, whether new techniques are needed, and where and how dredged material is disposed of
- MMO must ensure that all the current conditions on its licence are met and should include pyridine in the testing as part of any future licence approval process
- All dredged material should be tested for pyridine and any found with dangerous levels should be removed from the sea
- Maintenance dredging to be kept to the minimum level needed to keep the port operational until the expert panel's investigation is completed
- Routine checks for pyridine as part of the testing and approval for any new capital dredging works until the cause of the deaths is known
- Any current capital dredging work and new licences issued after the conclusion of the expert panel's investigation must take account of the outcome of that investigation
However, Sir Robert made clear he was not calling for an end to maintenance dredging.
"A complete moratorium on maintenance dredging would eventually close the port and its associated industries, causing further economic damage," he said.
Fishermen off the North East coast have said their industry has been devastated by large wash-ups of dead crustaceans.
In light of their plight, Sir Robert also called on the government to set up dedicated, separate funding for affected fishers and potters as well as for the regeneration of crab and lobster stocks.
The South Tees Development Corporation, which has been undertaking non-maintenance dredging in the Tees Estuary, said: "There is no evidence that dredging for the South Bank Quay has contributed to the marine deaths.
"The Tees Valley Mayor continues to push government for financial support for those fishermen whose livelihoods have been affected by this issue."
Paul Grainger /PA Wire
Follow BBC North East & Cumbria on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram. Send your story ideas to [email protected].