Reality Check: Brexit can be win-win for UK and Europe, says Theresa May

Getty Images Theresa May and a cameramanGetty Images

Theresa May has delivered her long-awaited speech on Brexit, giving more details of what she wants from the UK's future trade arrangements with the European Union.

Here are some of the key lines from the speech.

Text from Theresa May speech saying: There is no escaping the complexity of the task ahead of us.

There was a time when government ministers were suggesting that this was going to be the easiest negotiation in history.

That rhetoric has gone. The prime minister suggested that there would be difficult days ahead, and inevitable points of disagreement.

The bottom line is that Mrs May still intends to take the UK out of the single market and the customs union.

But she emphasised that both sides stand to gain from the successful negotiation of a new partnership, whereas the EU still sees Brexit not as a win-win but as a lose-lose.

Quote from Theresa May speech: As Prime Minister of the whole United Kingdom, I am not going to let our departure from the European Union do anything to set back the historic progress that we have made in Northern Ireland - nor will I allow anything that would damage the integrity of our precious Union.

After the uproar of the past couple of days, the prime minister decided that she needed to address Northern Ireland early on.

It was a re-statement of what was agreed last December - no hard border with the Republic, but no customs border with the rest of the UK either.

The trouble is there wasn't much detail about how that circle can be squared. Later in the speech she did speak about the use of technology at the border and a streamlined customs arrangement or even a new-style customs partnership (but not a customs union).

Scepticism about the UK position in Dublin, and elsewhere in Europe, won't have eased all that much.

Text from Theresa May's speech saying: I want to be straight with people - because the reality is that we all need to face up to some hard facts. We are leaving the single market. Life is going to be different. In certain ways, our access to each other's markets will be less than it is now. How could the EU's structure of rights and obligations be sustained, if the UK - or any country - were allowed to enjoy all the benefits without all of the obligations?

Yes, the prime minister says to the EU, you have a point - we can't just pick off the good bits (although there will be those who argue that she tries to do just that later in the speech).

But there was an honest appraisal here of the "hard facts" - notably that market access will be less than it is now, and that the UK will still have to take account, in some respects, of the rulings of the European Court of Justice.

It was a realistic appraisal of where any successful negotiation is likely to end. On the other hand, the prime minister insisted that the UK will still want to demonstrate that it has taken back control of its money, its border, and its laws.

Text from Theresa May's speech saying: I want the broadest and deepest possible partnership - covering more sectors and co-operating more fully than any Free Trade Agreement anywhere in the world today. And we will also need agreements in a range of areas covering the breadth of our relationship.

There's nothing wrong with being ambitious, but there will be those who point out that the broadest and deepest possible partnership anywhere in the world today is enshrined in the EU's single market and customs union.

It was striking in this speech how much of the current relationship Mrs May wants to keep - staying close, for example, to EU regulatory agencies, to environmental and consumer protection laws, and to EU policies on state aid and fair competition.

But the prime minister also reserved the right to diverge from EU policies where necessary. In Brussels and elsewhere, that will still be seen as cherry-picking, and will be unacceptable to EU negotiators who are determined to protect the integrity of the single market.

Text from Theresa May speech saying: The UK will need to make a strong commitment that its regulatory standards will remain as high as the EU's. That commitment, in practice, will mean that UK and EU regulatory standards will remain substantially similar in the future.

This was important. A bonfire of EU regulations is not going to happen. And if the UK can successfully negotiate a new model of associate membership of EU agencies, that regulate chemicals, pharmaceuticals and the aviation industry, large sections of UK business will breathe a sigh of relief.

Mrs May offered to pay for access to these agencies, and much of the expertise the EU relies upon is based in the UK. But there will still be disagreements about judicial oversight and the role of the European Court of Justice.

It is another reminder of how much there is to negotiate in an extraordinarily short period of time, and why a transition period after Brexit will be so important.

Text from Theresa May speech saying: We recognise that certain aspects of trade in services are intrinsically linked to the single market and therefore our market access in these areas will need to be different.

Mrs May called for a bold and creative agreement on services - a sector of over-riding importance to the UK economy.

She mentioned two sectors in particular - broadcasting and financial services - that have never been properly covered in a free trade agreement before.

Her argument is a familiar one - restricting access in all areas of economic activity will hurt you as much as it hurts us.

She spoke of the UK and the EU maintaining the same regulations over time while accepting there would be "consequences" (loss of market access) if the UK chose a different path.

On the one hand, it doesn't sound like "ambitious managed divergence" and that may not be acceptable to some supporters of Brexit in the UK.

On the other hand, it does mean the UK sticking to some EU rules and not others - and that will not be acceptable in other capitals around Europe.

Or as the prime minister said in her speech: "This is a negotiation and neither of us can have exactly what we want."

Presentational grey line
Reality Check branding
Presentational grey line