Birmingham bin strike halted after court ruling

Birmingham's bin strike has been suspended after the High Court granted an interim injunction against the council's bid to make workers redundant.

A trial will take place to determine if the council acted unlawfully in issuing redundancy notices.

Workers have been on strike since 30 June.

Union members asked the court to grant the order against the council's bid to lose staff and change working patterns.

In a statement the council said it accepted the ruling.

The hearing in London on Wednesday centred on former council leader John Clancy's actions after he reneged on a deal to keep workers' jobs.

He quit last week amid widespread criticism of his U-turn.

Referring to Mr Clancy and his officers, Mr Justice Fraser said: "Neither party comes out of this sorry saga with any credit at all - I could use the words remarkable, extraordinary and more."

Conciliation service Acas said on 16 August the council had accepted the workers' case and restored the jobs of grade three workers, who are responsible for safety at the back of refuse vehicles.

However, a council report said the deal struck by Unite and the council was unaffordable.

The Unite union claims restructuring plans threaten the jobs of more than 120 staff, while the council says plans will modernise the service and save £5m a year.

Several refuse workers were at the hearing, one hailed the judge's decision as "fantastic" and a "massive victory".

The judge said Mr Clancy's "motivation was difficult to fathom".

Mr Fraser read out an email sent on 15 August from the interim chief executive Stella Manzie to ex-leader Mr Clancy saying the council could not look weak and "as if it's being walked over".

Documents make clear there was an internal rift at the council, Mr Fraser said.

A Birmingham City Council spokesperson said: "The council wants to offer the best possible refuse service for citizens and wants to work with Unite and all the other unions to do this.

"We remain committed to resolving the dispute as quickly as possible and we hope Unite will support us in doing this."

Unite assistant general secretary Howard Beckett said refuse workers would now return to a full working day.

"As part of the ruling Unite will suspend its industrial action until the matter is put before a full court hearing at a later date," he said.

The trial is likely to last five days and will be scheduled for the end of November.

However, Judge Fraser urged all parties to come to an agreement before the prospect of an "expensive trial".

The union is also repeating its calls for Ms Manzie, the authority's interim chief executive, to stand down.

Make no mistake - today's High Court judgement to temporarily stop 106 binmen losing their jobs is a huge blow to Birmingham City Council.

Mr Justice Fraser couldn't have been clearer in his scathing remarks about the "sorry saga" that led to this action.

He dismissed the council's argument that Mr Clancy had no authority to make a deal at ACAS with Unite, saying he was more than satisfied there's enough evidence of what was referred to in court as the 'Clancy Agreement' to be tested at a full trial.

He also dismissed a submission by Birmingham City Council's legal team that a trial would not be in the public interest.

However, he did urge all parties to come to some kind of agreement before the prospect of an expensive five-day trial in November.