Man guilty of army veteran hammer attack murder

Cumbria Police A mugshot of Jack Crawley. He has short brown hair and is wearing a grey T-shirt.Cumbria Police
Jack Crawley attempted to burn Paul Taylor's body, before burying him in woodland

A man who bludgeoned an army veteran to death with a hammer has been found guilty of murder.

Paul Taylor, 56, from Annan, Dumfriesshire, went missing last October and his remains were found in a shallow grave in woodland near Carlisle, Cumbria, in May.

Jack Crawley, 20, of Carlisle, also tried to burn his victim's body, a trial at the city's crown court heard.

He will be sentenced on Wednesday.

Crawley was also found guilty of the attempted murder of a man in York in January, who he met on the gay dating app Grindr and also attacked with a hammer.

He was on bail for the killing of Mr Taylor at the time.

Meanwhile, a second man on trial, Marcus Goodfellow, 20, also of Carlisle, was found not guilty of assisting an offender by helping to dispose of Mr Taylor’s vehicle.

Cumbria Police Paul Taylor. He is wearing a suit and tie and is smiling at the camera. He has short grey hair and blue eyes.Cumbria Police
Paul Taylor went missing in October 2023 and his remains were found in May

Crawley had been in touch with Mr Taylor for some time before the killing and they had previously met to have sex, the court heard.

Mr Taylor lived in Annan with his wife Maria.

The court heard his family was unaware of his sexual interest in men.

Crawley bludgeoned Mr Taylor in the head at least 10 times.

He then attempted to burn his victim's body before burying him at Finlandrigg Woods near Carlisle.

Police bodycam footage shows murderer Jack Crawley in custody

Crawley was arrested in Bristol on 2 February.

During his police interview in relation to the incident in York, he claimed he was acting in self-defence when he hit the man with a hammer.

Crawley led police to Mr Taylor's skeletal remains on 1 May, 195 days after he was reported missing by his wife.

Crawley, of no fixed address, had admitted manslaughter, but denied murder throughout the trial, which began on 1 October.

'Horrendous and indescribable'

A police van with branding on it that reads: "Crime Scene Investigation" is parked outside an area of woodland. A white tent can be seen in the distance and a police cordon surrounds it. Someone in a white hazmat suit is walking towards the van.
Paul Taylor's body was discovered in a shallow grave in Finglandrigg Wood

Det Supt Ian Hussey of Cumbria Police said he did not believe there were further victims, but the force was investigating and could not be "complacent".

In a statement issued after the verdict, Mr Taylor's family said their lives had been "completely torn apart".

"Losing Paul in these circumstances and the torment and hurt this has caused has been horrendous and indescribable," they said.

Follow BBC Cumbria on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram. Send your story ideas to [email protected]

Related internet links