Call for council leader to quit in bin strikes row

James Bovill
BBC Midlands Today
Andrew Dawkins
BBC News, West Midlands
BBC At least 10 black bin bags on the ground, with some items loose. A tree and cars are in the background.BBC
Overflowing bins and mounds of rubbish, like in this picture taken on Wednesday in Brandwood, have been seen in parts of Birmingham at times during the strikes

A union is calling for Birmingham's council leader to quit over what it called the authority's "abhorrent" and "shambolic" handling of the city's bin strike.

Talks broke down on Wednesday with the council saying it was "walking away", after conciliation service Acas had started mediating negotiations in May.

Leader John Cotton said the authority had "sought to be reasonable and flexible but we have reached the absolute limit of what we can offer".

Unite's national lead officer Onay Kasab said on Thursday: "The way his council under his leadership has mishandled this dispute and with yesterday's appalling announcement, as a Labour councillor he really needs to be considering his position."

In response, a spokesperson for the city council did not comment on calls for Cotton to consider his position but said they would be talking to staff and unions about their next steps.

The union walked out on strike after claiming 170 workers would face losing up to £8,000 a year due to the council's decision to remove Waste Recycling and Collection Officer (WRCO) roles.

Mountains of rubbish have been seen across the city at points during the strikes, since bin collection workers walked out in January, with an all-out strike going on since March.

Five wheelie bins, with some overflowing, and a number of binbags by a road. Properties are in the background.
An all-out bin strike began in March in Birmingham (photo from Wednesday in Brandwood)

On Wednesday, Unite general secretary Sharon Graham repeated earlier claims that the council had resorted to a "fire and rehire" strategy.

Accusing the council of a "shambolic" mishandling of the dispute, including a "daft" attempt to negotiate via a statement to the media, Mr Kasab said on Thursday of Cotton: "I think he really has to seriously consider his position."

The national lead officer also stated there had "not been numerous offers that the union has turned down".

"The question to the council is how do redundancies and cuts to people's pay improve services," he added.

"That's the question that John Cotton really has to answer now."

A number of bins bags are on the pavement along with other rubbish by the road sign.
This illustrates the scale of the rubbish by the Grove Cottage Road sign in Small Heath on Thursday

The council leader said on Wednesday that the authority had "now run out of time", after negotiating in good faith.

Cotton added "unfortunately Unite has rejected all offers so we must now press ahead to both address our equal pay risk and make much needed improvements to the waste service".

The Labour-run council would communicate with staff and unions as to its next steps, with voluntary redundancy remaining on the table alongside opportunities for training and redeployment, the leader said.

A man with white hair and a white top is looking at the camera. Black bin bags are blurred on the photo on the pavement on the right.
Shafaq Hussain said an independent panel representative of Birmingham communities ought to get involved

Residents and workers in the city have since been reflecting on the continuing stalemate, with some calling for the views of the public to be formally represented during discussions.

Chair of the End the Bin Strike campaign Shafaq Hussain said he thought it was "appalling" that the leader of the city council had "decided to walk away from the table".

Mr Hussain stated: "We feel that if they can't come to an agreement, then an independent panel representative of Birmingham communities ought to really get involved."

Taking stock of conditions on the ground, a GP in Small Heath Dr Avanti Sarma said there had been many instances "where our staff, including my manager, had to come out and clean".

She stated that traditionally "this area has had a rodent problem".

Dr Sarma added: "(A private agency) said in some of the other premises, not ours, they've started even to break through the brick walls.

"We have to keep our windows closed. We cannot open our sunroofs... because of the smell, because of the flies."

A man with a black T-shirt with the words The Rolling Stones in white is wearing glasses and has a moustache. Properties and cars are in the background.
Resident Steve Burgess said he sympathised with refuse workers

Small Heath resident Steve Burgess said bins were now emptied regularly, but "the rubbish does accumulate at the end of the street".

Asked who he sympathised with, he replied: "I sympathise with the bin men to be honest... It's up to the council (for) me to sort it out."

Follow BBC Birmingham on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.

Related internet links