Protesters barred from disrupting degree ceremony

Brian Farmer
BBC News, Cambridgeshire
Reporting fromRoyal Courts of Justice
PA Media A protest camp in Cambridge. There are green, blue and white tents pitched on grass. One person wearing a black T-shirt and red and white scarf is walking in the centre of the site. A hand-written sign saying "DIVEST NOW" is pinned to one tent. On the left of the tents is a brown stone wall. PA Media
Pro-Palestine campaigners have staged protests in Cambridge after the Gaza conflict began in late 2023

A High Court judge has barred pro-Palestinian campaigners from disrupting a Cambridge University graduation ceremony.

Mr Justice Fordham imposed an injunction covering a ceremony due to take place on Saturday, following an application by lawyers representing the university.

They had raised longer-term concerns about ceremonies being disrupted, but failed to persuaded the judge to impose a wider injunction.

A union had condemned the university legal action as a "shameful" attack on democratic rights.

Protest camps were set up in Cambridge following the outbreak of conflict in Gaza, between Israel and Hamas, in late 2023.

Pro-Palestinian campaigners had alleged that Cambridge University had not acted on previous agreements to review investments in relation to the arms industry.

Lawyers told Mr Justice Fordham how protests had disrupted a number of degree ceremonies.

They asked him to make an order covering four university premises in Cambridge, which would last until 2030.

PA Media Cambridge protesters, with some wearing scarves and dark glasses, hold up signs and red, green and white flags. PA Media
Protests have been staged in Cambridge over many months

Barrister Yasser Vanderman, who led the university's legal team, said some "defendants" formed part of a "well organised" group with "strong and committed" views on the conflict.

The university wanted "injunctive relief" to "restrain threatened acts of trespass and nuisance", he said.

Mr Vanderman asked for an injunction to last five years - with annual reviews - arguing that given the "long-standing nature" of the Gaza conflict, such a time-frame was reasonable.

But the judge said he was not prepared to make any "final" order - or any order lasting five years.

He granted an injunction focused on a ceremony due to take place at Senate House, on Trinity Street, on Saturday.

The judge said only a limited order, which would last until 23:00 GMT on Saturday, was justified. He said he aimed to reconsider the case in the near future.

No protesters were at Thursday's hearing in London and none were represented by lawyers. The university took the legal action against "persons unknown".

A lawyer said, after the hearing, that the injunction would run through Friday and Saturday and, in essence, bar anyone from entering Senate House, or nearby Senate House Yard, without university permission.

Lawyers said anyone thought to have breached the order could face legal action and be found in contempt of court.

PA Media Four punts filled with people making their way along a river. A stone bridge is in the background. A tree overhangs on the left. A grass bank and shrubs are on the right.PA Media
Anyone caught disrupting Saturday's ceremony in Cambridge could face legal action

A number of organisations had condemned the university's injunction application.

The University and College Union (UCU), campaign group Liberty and the Palestine Solidarity Campaign raised concerns.

Jo Grady, UCU general secretary, said it was a "shameful attack on basic democratic rights".

However, Cambridge University had said any claim that it was trying "restrict protest" was "ridiculous", adding it was trying to protect students and staff.

Brian Farmer/BBC A grey stone building with the words "Royal Courts of Justice" written in black on the side of a wall.Brian Farmer/BBC
The High Court hearing was staged at the Royal Courts of Justice complex in London

Follow Cambridgeshire news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.